Unfortunately this situation is not too out of the ordinary, people who are constantly connected to their email, and others through text messaging don't realize how disrespectful it is to be in conversation or spending time with someone while completely distracted by their phone. I can't think of any email that is so important that it needs to be checked at the very instant it is sent, at the expense of ignoring others in the room. If I was spending time with someone would it be acceptable for me to take out stationary and ink and start writing a letter, I don't think so, yet my generation finds it acceptable to do the same thing through their phone. I really cannot stand when I make plans with someone and half of the person isn't even in the world but rather on their phone texting. For example I once went on a date, at the restaurant the girl was constantly texting people, clearly distracting her for the most important person in the room... ME. Let's just say that was a first sign it wouldn't work out between us. Imagine being on a date an all of a sudden I decide to call my friend and talk about the tiger's games, I would not expect my date to be to happy. Yet when texting it is socially acceptable. I know each of us will catch a student texting in class thinking they are being discreet, and yet texting is so intertwined in teens life today that they'll often text when it is not socially acceptable and think that it is.
Personally I hate texting. I text as little as possible, and really only text because has become such a prevalent form of communication, that I would be able to communicate with certain people if I didn't text. While I understand the value of texting as a means of quick communication, I feel as though another major reason people text is because of how depersonalized it is. In terms of human interaction, face to face is highest, calling on the phone removes the visual, and texting removes the auditory. When texting the person is so far removed from the person receiving the text, they feel empowered to say things they otherwise wouldn't. You wouldn't believe some of the things I've seen my male friends text girls, that they wouldn't be caught dead saying in person or over the phone. People refer to alcohol as "liquid confidence" I would call texting "technological confidence." And yet whether I agree or not it is completely intertwine in today's social interaction.
The article spoke at length about how Generation M doesn't distinguish there private life from public life on the internet. I heard a comedian recently say a joke along the lines "remember when people kept their diaries private. Sally used to freak out when she caught reading her diary especially where it said she was pregnant, yet now Sally will just update her status 'OMG just got preggers! Should I name it Scooba or Winnebago.'" While todays teens keep online diaries and put lots of information they are clearly aware what they put online, who's most likely going to look at it, and how they feel they'll be judged by others based on what information they provided. Take Facebook for example, I would bet that most of my class mates carefully chose what information to put in their profile, and have changed that information at times, I know I have. When I created my profile I was asking people to judge me based on what I chose to include about myself. The information I provided isn't really the whole me. I specifically chose not to include Sleepless in Seattle as one of my favorite movies or Barry Manilow as my favorite musical artist, for fear of being judged harshly by others on Facebook. But really has anyone ever seen in anything negative in their personal information, I will give a dollar to anyone who can find someone who puts coke addict in their about me section. When I made my profile I carefully decided to include I wide variety of musical artist as my favorite. I thought at the time people would see my my musical preferences and say to themselves "Wow David has such an eclectic taste in music, he must really be cool," as if my musical preferences really describes who I am. I have never once had comment on my favorite music section. My point is that while their is plenty of information online those who put it there are quite deliberate, just as I've been deliberate in writing this online journal of sorts.
To reward those who made it this far, some info about me that you won't find on my facebook profile:
1) I use sesame street children's toothpaste
2) I didn't learn how to ride a bike until my teens
3) I secretly watch a lot of reality TV (Who thinks it's about time Tila Tequila joins the cast of Jersey Shore)
4) I am secretly Batman (please don't tell)
Your blog post popped into my Google Reader just as I was closing the laptop for the day ... and I couldn't stop reading. This is an incredibly powerful post. Your articulation that your online persona(e) is/are carefully constructed to meet the expectations of those in your social circle brings up important issues of how adolescent learners develop and articulate their sense of self. Does the online world enhance that sense? Or merely provide another venue in which they should conform? As you are just a month away from having class after class of adolescents, how does this realization about your own online behavior (carefully planned, carefully chosen) mesh with your understanding of how they behave? Do you see them as able to discern what they should/should not divulge? Do you see any online media that encourage authentic individuality over others? What do you see as your responsibility as their teacher?
ReplyDelete(P.S. I don't care if my iPhone makes cookies, but if it could just clean my floors, I'd be a happy woman. Is there a Roomba app?)
Dave,
ReplyDeleteI disagree with your opinion on texting. I love texting for the reason sometimes I have something to say to someone and I do not want to make a phone call. I view it as sending an email and getting a quick response back. Your friend on the other hand was a bit rude, who has to check emails that bad that they cannot converse with someone who is giving them a ride home. As for your expierence on that date, I can understand one or two quick texts but it is rude to be texting the whole time. However, on the other hand I think texting in a social situation is ok as long as you are still being interactive with the people around you.
Dave,
ReplyDeleteI completely relate to this post. I think I was the last person that I knew to finally get a cell phone and so far I think I'm that last one without texting. I agree with you that there should be some distance between us and technology, I don't need to know the second that I get a new e-mail and I don't think that someone should be waiting for my reply the exact instant that it's received. Nice post.
Dave,
ReplyDeleteI agree with a lot of what you are saying. I hate texting too, but I do it all the time. I have friends who will text me. Ill call them back, get their voicemail, and then they will text me with a response to my message. In addition, I cannot stand when people are sitting next to me texting while carrying on a conversation with me! so annoying.
I wonder if you would hate texting as much if you had a Blackberry..!? I hate that I'm a bit obsessed with my BB, always conscious of that blinking red light that signifies a text message or a bbm or an email... But its true that there is a time for texting and thats not when your roommates mom wants to get to know you a bit and especially not when you're on a date. I think people need to find this balance in order for us to live harmoniously with technology.
ReplyDeleteHave a nice day, Batman...
:)
Dave, I love it. I laughed, I cried, I threw my laptop against the wall, and then pieced it together so I could keep reading.
ReplyDeleteI think texting is a great resource and a valid form of communication. However, I get pissed when people rely on it too much. IT IS such a impersonal form of communication. My favorite is having a fight via text message. That is the most passive-aggressive behavior ever. I think texting has a place and a time in our society, I don't think it will ever take the place of a phone call or a face-to-face conversation. And I think it's funny how reliant people have become on texting. You make a very valid point.
Since we're sharing non-Facebook stuff:
1) I own a pair of footie pajamas
2) Can I be Robin?
Hi David,
ReplyDeleteI hope that you are enjoying your summer.
Your blog is so long I felt like I was reading a Qualitative article; only your writing is more interesting. You are so lucky that you can synthesize so much textual information so efficiently.
If I was your roommate I would have handed you the phone and let you process all my emails. I would have not ignored your mom for an entire hour.